359: The Dirty Secret About Who Really Controls the Cattle Market… Packers Exposed

On today's episode of the podcast, Lauren is joined by cattle market analyst John Campbell for one of the most eye-opening conversations yet about who really controls today's cattle market. John breaks down Alternative Marketing Agreements (AMAs), how fed cattle are priced, why negotiated cash trade continues to shrink, and what many producers don't realize about Certified Angus Beef premiums. Drawing from his own recent feedyard closeouts, he explains how plant averages, carcass grids, and packer leverage impact producer profitability. The conversation also explores why so many feedyards participate in AMAs despite the frustrations, how market concentration has changed the industry, and what could happen if cattle numbers eventually begin to rebuild.

Links

CattleUSA Insurance - https://info.cattleusainsurance.com/l/1102253/2025-06-04/288f5m

CattleUSA Website - https://www.cattleusa.com/

CattleUSA App IOS:
https://apps.apple.com/us/app/cattleusa/id1673147759

CattleUSA App Android:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.edgarmcbee.cusamobile&pcampaignid=web_share

Facebook -
https://www.facebook.com/cattleusamedia

Instagram -
https://www.instagram.com/cattleusa.media/

Subscribe to our newsletter -
https://www.cattleusa.shop/products/cattleusa-drive-premium-daily-newsletter?utm_source=ig&utm_medium=social&utm_content=link_in_bio&brid=YWdncwFNXt0EmdzFy5cJJBp84J9g

CattleUSA Media -
https://www.cattleusamedia.com/

Lauren's Instagram -
https://www.instagram.com/_laurenmoylan/

Lauren's YouTube -
https://www.youtube.com/@Showboatmediaco

The Next Generation Podcast Website -
https://www.thenextgenag.com/

Key Takeaways

• How Alternative Marketing Agreements (AMAs) actually work

• Why many producers never receive the premiums their cattle earn

• The truth behind Certified Angus Beef qualifications

• How plant averages determine premiums and discounts

• Why negotiated cash trade has become such a small percentage of the market

• How packers have gained significant leverage over fed cattle pricing

• Why many feedyards feel they have no alternative but to participate in AMAs

• The risks producers face if cattle supplies eventually rebuild

• Why market concentration continues to be one of the biggest issues facing the cattle industry today

• What producers need to understand before marketing finished cattle

  
  

Chapters

00:00 John returns to the podcast
03:10 Current fed cattle and feeder cattle market update
06:45 What is an Alternative Marketing Agreement (AMA)?
10:15 The truth about Certified Angus Beef premiums
15:45 How packers calculate premiums and discounts
21:00 Why negotiated cash trade keeps shrinking
26:30 Why producers still participate in AMAs
31:40 Could today's cattle market structure survive herd rebuilding?
37:15 Final thoughts on the future of cattle marketing

Alternative Marketing Agreements, AMA cattle, cattle markets, fed cattle, feeder cattle, cattle pricing, packers, beef packers, negotiated cash trade, Certified Angus Beef, CAB premiums, cattle grids, carcass premiums, carcass pricing, cattle industry, beef industry, cattle marketing, fed cattle pricing, livestock markets, ranching, cattle producers, beef production, feedlots, independent cattle producers, cattle economics, John Campbell, CattleUSA Podcast, agriculture podcast