Episode 187: Kutchie’s Key Lime Pie, A Quirky Internet Mystery feat. Believing The Bizarre

SKIP TO 00:11:00 TO GET TO THIS WEEK’S STORY! Welcome to Episode 187: Kutchie’s Key Lime Pie, A Quirky Internet Mystery! Around 2009, a flurry of bizarre, copy pasta-esque comments began appearing across the internet in droves. These strange comments referenced a now-defunct restaurant named Kutchie’s Café which allegedly sold the best key lime pie in the world, a pie capable of giving people “piegasms”, baked by “Captain Kutchie” himself. For the next 8 years, this unknown person posted over 700 comments from over 30 different usernames before one day just disappearing…leaving the public with no explanation for their odd behavior. This user would later become known as the “Key Lime Pie” poster, or simply “KLP”, and the mystery he or she left behind would be cemented in the Internet Mystery hall of fame as the internet rabbit hole known as “Kutchie’s Key Lime Pie”. So, who was the KLP Poster? Was he posting in code for military spies? Was he a disgruntled ex-employee, Captain Kutchie himself, an SEO botscript gone rogue, a troll, or something else entirely? Join Aly and Nat with special guests Tyler and Charlie of Believing the Bizarre as they attempt to unravel a zany mystery that is sure to turn your brain to mush. TIME STAMPS 00:00:00 - PERSONAL HAUNTING 00:11:00 - MIRACLE BRAND AD 00:13:00 - PART I: INTERNET RABBIT HOLES 00:26:15 - BETTER HELP AD 00:28:00 - PART II: KUTCHIE’S KEY LIME PIE 00:48:45 - BLISSY AD 00:50:55 - PART II CONTINUES 01:09:20 - FUM AD 01:11:52 - PART II CONTINUES 01:26:28 - INTERVIEW WITH JUDD, FORMER PATRON OF KUTCHIE’S 01:33:42 - PART III: THE THEORIES 01:58:00 - CLOSING CREDITS Link to TikTok referenced in Part I: https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZPREG45Xm/ BE SURE TO GIVE BELIEVING THE BIZARRE A LISTEN! VISIT THEIR WEBSITE: https://believingthebizarre.com LISTEN TO THEM ON SPOTIFY: https://bit.ly/3FdoxMh —— THIS EPISODE IS SPONSORED!! Find out more about this week’s advertisers below! Miracle Made: Go to https://TryMiracle.com/HAUNTED and use code “HAUNTED” to claim your FREE 3 PIECE TOWEL SET and save over 40% OFF! Better Help: This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp! Give online therapy a try at https://www.betterhelp.com/GETHAUNTED to get on your way to being your best, least haunted self. BLISSY: Get better sleep now with Bliss and use code “LGHPOD” to get an additional 30% off at https://blissy.com/LGHPOD FUM: Start the Good Habit at https://tryfum.com/HAUNTED to save 10% off the Journey Pack today. —— Other Important Stuff: Join the Patreon today! https://patreon.com/letsgethaunted LGH Link Tree: https://linktr.ee/letsgethaunted Buy Our Merch: https://www.letsgethaunted.com Check out the photo dump for this week’s episode: https://www.instagram.com/letsgethaunted Send us fan mail: PO BOX 1658 Camarillo, CA 93011 Send us your listener stories: LetsGetHauntedPod@gmail.com —— BACKGROUND MUSIC [1] “MAGIC TRANSITION SOUND - NO COPYRIGHT” BY SOUND TRUST, LINK: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vNHMu3Upgu4 [2] License Dar Golan - Elevator Music - Royalty free music, “Elevator Music (Royalty Free, Infinite Loop)” by Dar Golan, free download link here: https://www.dargolan-free.com/funny-music [3] “Scene of the Crime” - David Fesliyan [4] “Scene of the Crime” - David Fesliyan Fesliyan Studios purchase license code ae95291c-ecf5-40ad-8622-9dc083b7cf8d KEYWORDS: Horror, scary, storytelling, halloween, cryptid, legend, urban legend, haunted, haunting, ghost, creature, reddit, 4chan, TikTok, Tumblr, spooky, paranormal, supernatural, alien, key lime pie, shitpost, troll, Arden, Asheville, North Carolina, jimmy Buffett, key west, Florida, internet, mystery Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices