27 | Sherri Papini | Houdini Papini
The three mustaches discuss the absolutely bonkers disappearance of Sherri Panini. Sherri, who disappeared on November 2, 2016, reportedly while out jogging a mile from her home in Redding, Californi...
18 Juli 20242h 37min
26| Heather Strube | Mother-In-Law Outlaw
It's a mustache's birthday, our special boy Coop... so this episode gets out of control as we discuss the murder of a young mother, Heather Strube. On April 26, 2009, Heather was gunned down in broad ...
11 Juli 20241h 18min
25| Holly Williams and Bill Lanway| Toyota Escort
The three mustaches discuss how the owner of a Texas Toyota dealership in downtown Austin, an escort from Nashville, a neighborhood drunk, and an Israeli hitman in North Carolina are somehow connected...
4 Juli 20241h 21min
24 | Brad McGarry | The Coal Miner's Lover
The three mustaches discuss the murder of coal miner, Brad McGarry. In May of 2017, 43-year-old Brad McGarry's body was discovered in the basement of his home in Bellaire, Ohio. The officials initiall...
27 Juni 20241h 10min
23 | Judy Malinowski | Rising from the Ashes
The three mustaches apologize in advance for this case, although they dare you to not be inspired by the story of Judy Malinowski. Mother-of-two Judy, was doused in gasoline and set on fire by her cra...
20 Juni 20241h 28min
22 | Jennifer Schuett | Beware of Jenn's Revenge
The three mustaches discuss the disturbing but uplifting tale of Jennifer Schuett. Jennifer Schuett, an eight-year-old girl, was abducted from her bedroom by a man posing as a police officer. She was ...
13 Juni 202452min
21 | Victoria Cilliers | Faulty Parachutes and Glory Holes
On Easter Sunday 2015, experienced skydiver Victoria Cilliers undertook a parachute jump, a gift from her husband, British army sergeant Emile Cilliers. However, during the skydive both her standard a...
6 Juni 20241h 7min
20 | Austin Lee Edwards | The Catfishing Cop
The three mustaches discuss Austin Lee Edwards, the police officer who catfished a girl, 15, and then killed three members of her family after pretending he was a detective to get into their Californi...
30 Maj 20241h 2min
