131 | Trenton Berry | Youth of the Nation
The three mustaches circle around the campfire to tell some hunting stories about the one that got away. One that definitely DIDN'T get away was Kirt Stubbins. In 2023, he took his girlfriend's 17-yea...
30 Juli 1h 33min
130 | Dannemora Prison | The Dick, The Sweat, and the Seamstress
The three mustaches keister some shanks and put on their scary faces because they're going to the big house. In 2015, a pair of cons from New York orchestrated a prison break so complex that it rivale...
23 Juli 2h 16min
129 | Albert Seedman | Mobsters and Magic Bullets
The three mustaches don their trench coats and fedoras to solve a few cases with the hardest dick in New York history, Albert Seedman. Whether they were a murderer, a mafioso, or a mob of religious f...
16 Juli 1h 26min
128 | Branden Banfield | The Au Pair Affair
The three mustaches tackle a spicy and sensational case that has all of our favorite things, and more. In 2023, a bizarre home invasion gone wrong in Herndon, Virginia resulted in the deaths of both t...
9 Juli 2h 14min
127 | Susan Monica | Like Lipstick on a Pig... Farmer
The three mustaches head to rural Oregon to help track down a guy named Robert Haney. According to his enchantingly beautiful landlord / employer, Susan Monica, he went hog wild a few months ago and s...
2 Juli 1h 33min
125 | Joyce McKinney | The Manacled Mormon Part One
The three mustaches head to jolly old England to cover the controversial case of the Manacled Mormon. In 1977, an American missionary named Kirk Anderson vanished from a Latter-day Saints church in Su...
29 Juni 1h 38min
126 | Joyce McKinney | The Manacled Mormon Part Two
The three mustaches reconvene to finish the scandalous tale of Joyce McKinney and the Manacled Mormon. When we last left off, Joyce and her friend-zoned lackey, Keith May, had just been arrested for t...
25 Juni 1h 43min
124 | Timothy Molnar | Into the Waukesha
The OG mustaches are joined by their new producer, Bluke, to discuss the mysterious disappearance of Timothy Molnar. In 1984, Tim left his home in Daytona Beach, Florida, to attend classes at Embry-Ri...
11 Juni 1h 14min
