22. Pessimism of the Intellect, Optimism of the Will

What does it mean to hold both clear-eyed despair and committed action at the same time? I trace the antifascist axiom "pessimism of the intellect, optimism of the will" through my own life — my late mother's instinctive class consciousness, my writing teacher Luciano's daily creative discipline, and my early Buddhist practice of contemplating impermanence. I unpack Eve Sedgwick's concept of paranoid versus reparative reading, and why the left's hypervigilance can foreclose on the energy needed for repair. I correct the common attribution of the mantra to Gramsci, locating the phrase's origin in Romain Rolland's 1920 review of Raymond Lefebvre's WWI novel — a cry from Flanders Fields about bourgeois sacrifice of the young. And I map the tension between intellect and will onto bodily experience, arguing that theory and mutual aid aren't competing demands but two characteristics of how we already live.

Sources

Romain Rolland, review of Le Sacrifice d'Abraham, L'Humanité, 19 March 1920 — transcription and translation

Antonio Gramsci, "Address to the Anarchists," L'Ordine Nuovo, 3–10 April 1920

Raymond Lefebvre (1891–1920), Le Sacrifice d'Abraham (Flammarion, 1919)

Academic treatment of the phrase's history: "Pessimism of the Intellect, Optimism of the Will," Rethinking Marxism (2019)

Political reading of the slogan: "Pessimism of the Will," Viewpoint Magazine (2020)

Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick, "Paranoid Reading and Reparative Reading," in Touching Feeling: Affect, Pedagogy, Performativity (Duke University Press, 2003)

Bluesky: matthewremski.bsky.social

Instagram: @matthew_remski

YouTube: antifascistdad

TikTok: @antifascistdad

Patreon: antifascistdadpodcast

Pre-order Antifascist Dad: Penguin Random House

Chapters

(00:00:06) - Mark Carney lib-fash dad reflections
(00:01:56) - Pessimism of the Intellectuals vs optimism of the Will
(00:18:23) - A Week in the Life of Fascism

Denne episoden er hentet fra en åpen RSS-feed og er ikke publisert av Podme. Den kan derfor inneholde annonser.

Episoder(88)

46: How Capital Uses Workers’ Pensions Against Them w/ Kevin Skerrett

I sit down with Kevin Skerrett, a pension researcher who spent thirty years as a Senior Research Officer for CUPE and co-edited The Contradictions of Pension Fund Capitalism. We trace how Canadian pen...

30 Sep 1h 29min

UNLOCK: 44.1 Psychic Militancy w/ Dr. Lara Sheehi Pt. 2

Part two of my conversation with Dr. Lara Sheehi about her outstanding book From the Clinic to the Streets, focusing on how the "psychic intrusions" of confusion, fear, despair, and exhaustion functio...

27 Sep 58min

45: When Zionists Dominate Antisemitism Discourse w/ Daniel Sailofsky

Since October 7th, young people who have joined antifascist and anti-genocide organizing on campus have faced one of the most disorienting accusations available: that their solidarity with Palestinian...

23 Sep 1h

UNLOCK 43.1: Understanding Lebanon w/ Ayman Makarem Pt 2

Part two of my conversation with Ayman Makarem picks up where we left off: with Lebanon and Israel as co-developed colonial entities. We trace how the 1943 National Pact locked in a sectarian power-sh...

20 Sep 1h 5min

44. Psychic Militancy w/ Dr. Lara Sheehi

My guest today is militant Lebanese Arab clinical psychologist and psychoanalyst, Dr. Lara Sheehi, here to unpack her book From the Clinic to the Streets: Psychoanalysis for Revolutionary Futures. Fol...

16 Sep 56min

43. Understanding Lebanon w/ Ayman Makarem

Lebanon is once again on the front line of Israel's regional war, and a lot of leftist coverage, where there is any, flattens a hundred years of colonial history into campist slogans. In this episode ...

9 Sep 56min

UNLOCK 42.1 Friendship (is not easy)

An excerpt from the audiobook of Antifascist Dad: Urgent Conversations with Young People in Chaotic Times — Chapter Eight, Friendship Is Not Easy. I'm putting this out as a companion to my interview w...

9 Aug 43min

UNLOCK: 41.1 The Anti-Vance Would Like a Word Pt 2 w/ Nathan Evans Fox

Part 2 of my convo with Nathan Evans Fox, going deeper into the psychological and theological architecture of what JD Vance is actually doing in his new memoir, and what it costs him and everyone else...

2 Aug 45min