Witness Wednesday: Two Podcasters. One Case. What They Think Really Happened to Amy Bradley.

Carrie hosts Monstrous True Crime. She came across Amy Bradley's case the way most people do — searching for unsolved cases to cover, feeling an inexplicable pull to a story that clearly has answers somewhere. She reached out to the official Amy Bradley page. Sandy put her directly in contact. They spent two and a half hours on the phone. Sandy told her most of what's out there isn't correct. Carrie said: tell me what is. That was December. She's been working on it ever since.

In this Witness Wednesday episode, Carrie joins host Kevin Hall for a conversation between two independent podcasters who have been working the same case, with the same family, at the same time — and arriving at the same conclusions.

This conversation covers:

— The Netflix documentary: what it got right, what it got wrong, and why both Carrie and Kevin believe the focus on Amy's sexuality had nothing to do with advancing the case — and everything to do with getting views. "It diminishes her. She's so much more than that."

— The FBI: Carrie names agents Victor McCollum and Sheridan directly. "If they were my employees, I'd have fired their asses." Her reaction to learning what the male agent said to Lori: "Just two drunk rich white girls on vacation." Her take: "The FBI as an agency should be embarrassed by it."

— Royal Caribbean: all of the inconsistencies, the things not included in the reports, the things in interviews that contradict official records, Costello coaching Douglass on what to say, and a captain who said he had no procedure for a missing passenger. "How do so many people and so many agencies all fail at the exact same time, from the very beginning?"

— What they both think happened: Carrie lays out her theory — Amy and Douglass entered the Viking Lounge, she believes the drink was drugged, and Amy was taken down the crew elevator to the bottom of the ship and off in the early morning hours while most passengers were asleep. Kevin's head is in the same place. Both agree Douglass was central, that others on the ship likely knew, and that there are more players than just the bandmates.

— Social media and the cesspool of theories: why so many people cling to the walk-off and accident theories with no evidence, and Carrie's comparison to the only other case she's covered with a similar polarized online discourse — JonBenét Ramsey.

— When Monstrous True Crime's Amy Bradley episode drops: coming soon. Announcement coming when the date is set.

If you have information about Amy's disappearance — 1-800-CALL-FBI or tips.fbi.gov. Tips can be submitted anonymously. The FBI reward is now $100,000.

100% of Invisawear commissions go to the Bradley family's GoFundMe. 10% off through the link in the show notes. Support the show at no extra cost through our Amazon link.

📚 Echo 1953 — the first book in The Hollis Files mystery series — launches July 27th, 2026. Available for preorder on Amazon now. Link in the show notes.

#AmyBradley #AmyLynnBradley #AmyBradleyIsMissing #WitnessWednesday #MonstrousTrueCrime #MidnightMysteryArchive #TrueCrimePodcast #InvestigativePodcast #ColdCase #MissingPersons #BradleyFamily #RonBradley #IvaBradley #BradBradley #AlistairDouglass #LouCostello #RhapsodyOfTheSeas #RoyalCaribbean #CruiseShipDisappearance #FBIFailed #FBIReward #TrueCrimeDocumentary #DocumentarySeries #Echo1953 #TheHollisFiles #DebutNovel #InvisaWear #UnsolvedCases

Thanks to our monthly supporters

jared K
Lisa Mooney
Jamie Mcconnell

★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

Denne episoden er hentet fra en åpen RSS-feed og er ikke publisert av Podme. Den kan derfor inneholde annonser.

Episoder(155)

The Final Episode of MMA. 10,000 People in a Family Tree. One Name Left. | Kerryn Tate Pt. 2

This is the final episode of the Midnight Mystery Archive.In Part 1, we covered who Kerryn Tate was and what happened on December 29, 1979: a 22-year-old woman hitchhiking southeast of Perth, a delibe...

11 Sep 15min

Perth 1979. A Young Woman Accepted a Lift. 45 Years Later, They Named Who Did It. | MMA

This is the final series of the Midnight Mystery Archive — the last two-parter before the podcast goes on hiatus. It ends in Australia, one of MMA's largest listener bases, with a case that captures s...

4 Sep 18min

They Thought They Were Close. The 2023 Breakthrough Sent Them Back to Square One. | Deely Pt. 2

For 23 years, investigators and the public assumed the dark figure captured walking behind Trevor Deely on Haddington Road — 34 seconds after Trevor passed the camera — was the same man who had waited...

28 Aug 21min

Midnight Mystery Archive Is Going on Hiatus. Here's Why — and What's Still Coming. | MMA

An important update for every Midnight Mystery Archive listener.Kevin announced on social media Thursday, August 20th that MMA is going on extended hiatus. This episode is his direct message to the li...

24 Aug 5min

The Last Image of Trevor Deely Was at 4:14 AM. He Was Nine Minutes From Home. | MMA | Part 1

He was nine minutes from home. A man in dark clothing had been standing outside his office for 34 minutes before he got there. That was December 8, 2000. Trevor Deely has never been found. Trevor Deel...

21 Aug 24min

Trevor Deely Part 1 This Friday. Louisa Dunne Is Solved. And We're Not Done With Amy Bradley. | MMA Mini

Trevor Deely Part 1 drops this Friday. The Louisa Dunne two-parter is wrapped. And the Amy Bradley work is far from over. A quick Monday update on where we are and what's coming. Louisa Dunne. A 1967 ...

17 Aug 9min

How a Blue Skirt Preserved for 57 Years Convicted a Killer at 92. | Louisa Dunne Part 2

Part 1 covered the night of June 28th, 1967: Louisa Dunne, 75 years old, murdered in her home in Easton, Bristol. Part 2 covers how they finally found him. It started with a question asked in 2023 by ...

14 Aug 23min

Amy Bradley's Best Friend Saw Her the Night Before. She Speaks After Reading the Book. | MMA Special

She was the last friend to see Amy Bradley in Richmond — the night before the cruise. She's here to talk about the book.Stacie was Amy Bradley's best friend. On the night before she left for the cruis...

12 Aug 40min