The Murder of Joy Hayward with Jackie & Jenna from Stop, Who Does That?!

The cellphone was lying near Rachael Koloroutis. At 3:12 that afternoon, she had tried to call 911. But help never reached her in time. It was the afternoon of July 18, 2003, and four young people i...

30 Sep 1h 4min

Thank you to Riley for suggesting this episode! In July 2018, a heartbreaking crime shocked a quiet community when six-year-old Alesha MacPhail disappeared while visiting family on the peaceful Isle ...

23 Sep 1h 15min

In this special collaboration episode, Jen and Cam talk with Johanna and Annie from Fresh Hell of an American who disappeared while living abroad. In October 2007, 34-year-old Aeryn Michael John Gill...

21 Sep 1h 43min

As of the release of this episode, Christa Pike remains scheduled to be executed by lethal injection by the State of Tennessee on September 30, 2026. If that status changes or new information becomes ...

16 Sep 1h 22min

In October 1976, two teenagers took a late-night drive near a remote military base in the Missouri Ozarks and simply vanished into thin air. Months later, a second carload of kids was pulled over by...

9 Sep 1h 7min

In this special episode, Cam and Jen join forces with Ash from F**K That to unravel the haunting disappearance of Danielle Bell. Fourteen-year-old Danielle Arion Bell went missing on Friday, Septembe...

6 Sep 1h 15min

On a cold Saturday night in January 2007, 21-year-old Channon Christian and her boyfriend, 23-year-old Christopher Newsom, set out for a party. They never arrived. By the following afternoon, two fami...

2 Sep 1h 25min

Thank you to Mary and her partner for the request! Picture an endless stretch of highway surrounded by thick forests where there's no cell service, and towns are hours apart. Back in July 2019, that...

25 Aug 1h 2min