Dialogue on The Republic, Session 6: The Immortal Soul

Dialogue on The Republic, Session 6: The Immortal Soul

What is justice? This is the question that began The Republic, when Socrates and friends set out to find justice in the city in order to locate it in the citizens. In our final session on The Republic, on December 12, 2021, members of the Toronto Philosophy and Calgary Philosophy Meetup groups met to reach some conclusions. How does the soul reconcile its combination of rational limits and unlimited irrationality, to apply reason in the changing state of the present? It seems, to Socrates, that the soul requires harmony so that it is true and just to itself in following the mean that is the path between extremes. If the soul is immortal and incapable of its own destruction, as Socrates states, then does justice originate in the soul before it can be found in the city of mortals? We examined Socrates’ proof of the soul’s immortality, and the soul’s imitation of the eternal forms of being in the present, when the soul itself cannot be imitated and is its own derivative. What is the purpose of the curious myth of Er and its numbers and calculations, with which The Republic ends, and what does it tell us about the construction of the soul? Is time cyclic? Do the rewards for justice and penalties for injustice endure from one life to the next? We may consider these questions when we resume season 2 on January 9 when we will begin reading Plato’s Philebus.

Denne episoden er hentet fra en åpen RSS-feed og er ikke publisert av Podme. Den kan derfor inneholde annonser.

Episoder(77)

Alfred North Whitehead, Part 2: The Mathematician Who Added Plato to Modern Science

Alfred North Whitehead, Part 2: The Mathematician Who Added Plato to Modern Science

In their second episode featuring the works of modern Platonist Alfred North Whitehead (1861-1947), James Myers and Michael Fitzpatrick brought Plato into the 21st century through Whitehead’s perspect...

13 Apr 1h 22min

On Modern Platonist Alfred North Whitehead, Part 1: The Mathematician Philosopher

On Modern Platonist Alfred North Whitehead, Part 1: The Mathematician Philosopher

In this episode, James Myers and Michael Fitzpatrick continue to discuss modern Platonists with an introduction to Alfred North Whitehead (1861-1947), a mathematician who ended up as a professor of ph...

11 Feb 1h 20min

Why Artificial Intelligence is Impossible

Why Artificial Intelligence is Impossible

Plato’s Pod host James Myers brings the logic of the characters in ten of Plato’s dialogues to bear on the question of “what is intelligence?” and concludes that “artificial intelligence” is impossibl...

5 Jan 41min

Justice in Plato’s Time and Our Time: Words that Shape Constitutions, Justice, and Governments

Justice in Plato’s Time and Our Time: Words that Shape Constitutions, Justice, and Governments

Our choice and use of words has a profound effect on the operation of justice, and a particular legal dispute now before the United States Supreme Court hangs on the meaning of three words. In this ep...

15 Nov 202527min

On Modern Platonist Alain Badiou:"Thinking the Event" to Distinguish the Real from Images on the Wall

On Modern Platonist Alain Badiou:"Thinking the Event" to Distinguish the Real from Images on the Wall

“Think the event” is central to the philosophy of Alain Badiou, a modern Platonist who has been writing and lecturing in philosophy for over five decades. Badiou said, “Philosophy is the seizure of th...

22 Sep 20251h 52min

Plato’s Letters VI and VIII: Good Kings are Servants of the Laws and Justice

Plato’s Letters VI and VIII: Good Kings are Servants of the Laws and Justice

We followed our discussion of Plato’s famous Letter VII by looking at his lesser-known Letters VI and VIII. Together, they form a powerful trilogy in which “Love your neighbour” emerges as an overarch...

9 Mai 20251h 30min

Plato's Seventh Letter, Part 2: Can Virtue Be Taught?

Plato's Seventh Letter, Part 2: Can Virtue Be Taught?

The second half of our discussion on Plato’s Seventh Letter begins with a reading of Plato’s famous statement that he never published any statement of his opinions. That’s both the beauty and, for som...

7 Apr 20251h 33min

Plato's Seventh Letter: On Tyrants Who are Blind to Philosophy

Plato's Seventh Letter: On Tyrants Who are Blind to Philosophy

In our first discussion on Plato's letters, we look at his best-known Seventh Letter. In the letter, Plato relates his experience with Dionysius, the tyrannical ruler of Syracuse, and the philosophica...

3 Mar 20251h 17min

Populært innen Vitenskap

fastlegen
liberal-halvtime
romkapsel
jss
tingenes-tilstand
tomprat-med-gunnar-tjomlid
forskningno
rekommandert
rss-paradigmepodden
villmarksliv
rss-kunstig-intelligens-med-elisabeth-maren-og-morten
sinnsyn
rss-nysgjerrige-norge
fjellsportpodden
rss-rekommandert
tidlose-historier
nordnorsk-historie
rss-inn-til-kjernen-med-sunniva-rose
psykopoden
vett-og-vitenskap-med-gaute-einevoll