115 | The Alphabet Murders | Part One: The Victims
The three mustaches hop in their time machine and travel back to 1971 to tackle a case out of Rochester, New York. When the bodies of young girls began turning up along rural roads in upstate New York...
9 Apr 1h 9min
114 | Brenda Schaefer | Chili con Carnal
The three mustaches take a trip to Kentucky, and it's not for the fried chicken. In 1988, just outside of Louisville, 36-year-old Brenda Schaefer went missing after a dinner date with her soon-to-be e...
2 Apr 2h 6min
113 | Fabio Sementilli | Hairdresser Havoc
The three mustaches stock up on hairspray for a trip into the sordid underbelly of professional hairstylists. After spending 30 years clawing his way to the top of his industry, Fabio Sementilli was l...
26 Mar 2h
112 | Brian Wells | The Pizza Bomber
The three mustaches gas up their Geo Metro and strap on their explosive ordinance disposal suits to deliver some hot and fresh pizzas. Why would they need protective gear to deliver Italian food? We'r...
19 Mar 2h 17min
111 | Darlie Routier | Part Two: Death Row Diva
The three mustaches convene once again to go over all the facts and give the final verdict on the case of Darlie Routier. In the 30 years since Darlie was convicted of murder, new evidence has come to...
12 Mar 2h 45min
110 | Darlie Routier | Part One: Rude Awakening
The three mustaches grab their gavels and prepare to cast judgement on the controversial case of Darlie Routier. After a brutal home invasion left her two sons dead, investigators put Darlie in their ...
5 Mar 1h 31min
109 | Sydney Loofe | Witches of Wilber
The three mustaches stock up on garlic and holy water to hunt down a Midwest vampire. When Sydney Loofe met a young woman named Audrey on Tinder, she thought she had hit the jackpot. Audrey was fun, a...
26 Feb 1h 55min
108 | Melanie McGuire | The Suitcase Murder
The three mustaches grab their hair gel and touch up their spray tans to cover a controversial case from New Jersey. In the Spring of 2004, suitcases began washing up on the shores of the Chesapeake B...
19 Feb 2h
