Episode 141: "The Long Island Serial Killer"
A woman goes missing on Long Island near Gilgo Beach in May 2010. Her disappearance uncovers more than investigators could have imagined...the remains of many young women and eventually the identity o...
22 Jul 202451min
The New York Mystery Machine Trailer
Check out The New York Mystery Machine, the podcast that explores all of New York's mysteries, hauntings, true crimes, abductions, cryptids and more! Season 4's brand new episodes begin streaming on M...
15 Jul 202454s
BONUS: Adam Visits The Haunted Shanley Hotel (& Lives to Tell the Tale!)
Last week Adam took a trip up to Hudson and made a pit stop at The Haunted Shanley Hotel (covered in Episode 41). They had a VERY strange and frightening experience that they wanted to share with you ...
8 Jul 202416min
Episode 140: "Season 3 Finale! Updates, Hot Takes, and More!"
We have made it to another Season Finale! Today we are updating you on Venus Xtravaganza, NXIVM, The Brighton Axe Murder and even Isadore Fink! Plus we have your hot takes! Available wherever you stre...
24 Jun 20241h 3min
Episode 139: "Death by Dentist? Who Killed Dolly Reynolds?"
It's the late 1800's in NYC's Tenderloin District. Dolly Reynolds is found murdered in a hotel room and the only suspect is a dentist? But did he do it? Available wherever you stream podcasts! Be sure...
17 Jun 202447min
Episode 138: "The Life & Death of Venus Xtravaganza"
Venus Xtravaganza was a trans performer, popular in the 80's Ballroom Scene. She was young, vibrant, and bursting with energy. However, her life was cut short in this murder mystery. During this Pride...
11 Jun 202448min
Episode 137: "The Doll Shop Spy"
In 1944, wartime censors intercepted some very unusual letters encoded with information to the Japanese government. What were they saying? And who was behind them? Find out this week! Available where...
3 Jun 202446min
Episode 136: "The Poltergeists of Barberry Lane"
Hans Holzer is back on the show; and this time he is in Rye, New York and he is bringing his go-to mediums along to try and rid a Victorian style mansion of some angry spirits. Adam and Christina reen...
27 Mai 202459min
