Episode 119: "The Ballad of Lydia Sherman"
At first glance, the facts of Lydia's life might leave you thinking that this week we are exploring a curse placed upon an unsuspecting woman who lost all her children and was widowed three times over...
15 Jan 202443min
Episode 118: "Murder at The Met"
On July 23, 1980, a 30-year-old violinist named Helen Hagnes Mintiks does not return to her seat in the pit after the orchestra takes their break. She wouldn't be found until the next day when it was ...
8 Jan 202442min
Episode 117: "Missing on New Year's Day: Sam Todd"
New Year's Eve/Day in New York can be described as jubilant chaos - which makes it easy to get lost in the crowd. Sam Todd went for a breath of fresh air in the wee hours of the morning on New Year's ...
1 Jan 202443min
Episode 116: "The Legend of Krampus & the Many Strange Santas"
On this episode, we take a look at the darker lores of Christmas. That's right, we are talking about the Goat Monster Demon: Krampus! Is he real? Does he live in the USA? What about the other weird Sa...
18 Des 202351min
Episode 115: "Hauntings and Horrors at Rolling Hills Asylum"
Asylums were notorious for how poor they treated their "patients." Rolling Hills is no exception to that. In addition to brutal treatment, many residents even ended up making their own coffins. But, h...
11 Des 202353min
SPECIAL: The "Best" of 2023!
Christina couldn't be in-studio this week; so, instead, we put together an episode full of our favorite memories from the pod in 2023! We have accents, impressions, songs and other zany moments you ma...
5 Des 202347min
Episode 114: "The Cupcake Killer"
Okay...the title is a bit deceptive because cupcakes play little to no role in this murder case. BUT, they were there! An officer sees someone lighting matches in a church yard and stumbles upon a cor...
27 Nov 202342min
Episode 113: "A (K)nack for Murder: William Guldensuppe Loses His Head"
If you think you're having a rough day, imagine pulling a parcel out of the East River only to discover it's a dismembered torso. That's what happened to some boys in 1897 and over the next few days, ...
20 Nov 202339min
