Episode 57: "The Mad Bomber"
For over a decade, an unknown individual managed to terrorize the city with pipe bombs while evading the police. The Hunt for the perpetrator involved the psychiatrist who developed criminal profiling...
5 Sep 202247min
Episode 56: "Joel Rifkin: Serial Killer"
From 1989 through 1993 Joel Rifkin spent many evenings picking up sex workers, having sex with them, and brutally murdering them soon after. On this week's episode we take a deep dive into Rifkin the ...
29 Aug 202250min
Episode 55: "The Disappearance of Suzanne Lyall"
Suzanne Lyall was your average college student - studying, holding down two jobs, and navigating her dating life. After she got off the bus back to her campus one winter night, she was never seen agai...
22 Aug 202248min
Episode 54: "The Fox Sisters 'Discover' Spiritualism"
The Fox sisters, Leah, Margaretta, and Catherine, were three sisters from Rochester, New York who played an important role in the creation of Spiritualism. But were they communicating with the dead or...
15 Aug 202244min
Episode 53: "Heist at the American Museum of Natural History"
When three Miami surfers rob the American Museum of Natural History, a multi-state investigation ensues. But how did they get into one of the most famous museums and make off with some of the world's ...
8 Aug 202242min
Episode 52: "Surviving a Cult: An Interview with Former Members of The Odyssey Study Group"
In Season 1, we covered the harms perpetrated by Sharon Gans and the Odyssey Study Group - a cult that has preyed on people for decades. If you need a refresher, head back over to Episode 33. In this ...
1 Aug 20221h 7min
Episode 51: "The Amityville Horror"
Last week we focused on Chapter One of the Amityville Saga, the DeFeo Murders. This week, a new family has moved into the home and the paranormal has moved in with them! This episode has everything......
25 Jul 202253min
Episode 50: "The Amityville Murders"
Welcome to Season 2 of The New York Mystery Machine! This week we focus on the first part of the legendary Amityville Horror. On November 13, 1974, at around 6:30 p.m., 23-year-old Ronald "Butch" DeFe...
24 Jul 202246min
